PSA Suspends International Card Grading: What It Means for Collectors
In a move that has sent shockwaves through the collectibles market, Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) announced on June 10, 2024, that it will temporarily halt grading submissions from outside the United States. The decision, effective immediately, stems from operational challenges and a backlog of over 1 million unprocessed cards. Collectors worldwide now face uncertainty as the industry leader presses pause on international services indefinitely.
The Sudden Policy Shift and Its Immediate Impact
PSA, which grades approximately 70% of all trading cards worldwide, cited “unprecedented submission volumes and logistical complexities” as key reasons for suspending international services. The company’s online submission portal now displays a notice redirecting non-U.S. customers to domestic third-party intermediaries.
“This feels like a gut punch to the global collecting community,” remarked David Chen, founder of Hong Kong-based Elite Collectibles. “Many international collectors rely on PSA’s authentication to establish card values and facilitate cross-border trades.”
The suspension affects:
- Direct submissions from 150+ countries
- PSA’s partnered international grading centers
- All sports and non-sports trading cards
Market Reactions and Alternative Grading Options
Within 24 hours of the announcement, eBay reported a 12% drop in international card listings with PSA certification. Meanwhile, competitors like Beckett Grading Services (BGS) and SGC have seen submission inquiries spike by 30-40%.
“We’re prepared to handle increased international volume,” stated BGS President Ryan Hoge in a press release. “Our global authentication network remains fully operational.”
However, market analysts note significant differences in how grades translate to market value:
- PSA 10 cards typically command 15-20% premiums over BGS equivalents
- PSA’s registry system creates unique collector incentives
- Many auction houses require PSA/BGS dual certification for high-value lots
Why PSA’s Decision Could Reshape the Global Collectibles Market
The grading suspension arrives during a period of market correction. After the 2020-2022 boom that saw a 1951 Mickey Mantle card sell for $12.6 million, the trading card market contracted by 28% in 2023 according to PWCC Market Index data.
Logistical Challenges Behind the Move
Industry insiders suggest PSA’s international pause reflects deeper operational issues. The company reportedly struggles with:
- Customs delays affecting card returns
- Discrepancies in international grading standards
- Fraud risks from counterfeit submissions
“International submissions often require 30-45 additional processing days,” explained grading consultant Maria Rodriguez. “When combined with PSA’s current 120-day turnaround for bulk submissions, the timeline becomes unsustainable for many collectors.”
Collector Strategies in the Interim
Seasoned collectors are adapting through:
- Utilizing domestic U.S. intermediaries
- Exploring crossover grading (BGS to PSA when services resume)
- Focusing on raw card acquisitions
Not everyone views the suspension negatively. “This might help correct grading inflation we’ve seen recently,” argued veteran dealer James Whittaker. “PSA’s temporary retraction could restore scarcity value to already-graded international cards.”
The Road Ahead for International Card Collecting
PSA has not provided a timeline for resuming international services, though company representatives suggest “evaluating process improvements on a quarterly basis.” The decision leaves approximately $400 million in annual international grading revenue up for grabs among competitors.
Potential Long-Term Consequences
Market analysts predict several possible outcomes:
- Permanent market share loss for PSA in key Asian and European markets
- Increased standardization of BGS grading for international transactions
- Growth of regional grading services in markets like Japan and Australia
The situation remains fluid, but one truth emerges clearly: the global collectibles market must adapt to this seismic shift in authentication infrastructure. Collectors seeking guidance should consult reputable dealers and consider diversifying their grading service usage until the situation stabilizes.
For ongoing updates on this developing story, subscribe to our collectibles market newsletter or follow our expert analysis on social media.
See more Highlights Daily
