Unpacking the Red Sox’s First Base Dilemma: Devers vs. Mayer
The Boston Red Sox face a critical decision as they evaluate their options for first base, with star third baseman Rafael Devers and top prospect Nick Mayer emerging as potential candidates. As the 2024 season approaches, the organization must weigh Devers’ offensive firepower against Mayer’s defensive prowess and long-term upside. This strategic choice could reshape the team’s infield dynamics and future competitiveness.
The Case for Rafael Devers at First Base
Rafael Devers, a two-time All-Star and Silver Slugger winner, has anchored Boston’s lineup since his 2017 debut. The 27-year-old slugger boasts a career .281 batting average with 172 home runs and 555 RBIs through seven seasons. Moving Devers to first base would address several concerns:
- Defensive improvement: Devers has committed 129 errors at third base since 2017, including 19 in 2023
- Longevity: A position switch could reduce wear on his body and extend his prime years
- Lineup flexibility: Opens third base for other defensive specialists or emerging talent
“Devers has the offensive profile of a prototypical first baseman,” says MLB Network analyst Dan O’Dowd. “His bat plays anywhere, but moving him across the diamond could maximize his value while addressing defensive shortcomings.”
Nick Mayer’s Rising Stock and Defensive Edge
Meanwhile, 21-year-old Nick Mayer has rapidly ascended through Boston’s farm system since being drafted 4th overall in 2021. The left-handed hitter slashed .290/.366/.524 across Double-A and Triple-A last season while showcasing elite defensive skills. Mayer’s strengths present a compelling alternative:
- Gold Glove potential: 98.3% fielding percentage at first base in minors
- Contact skills: Just 18.7% strikeout rate in 2023 compared to Devers’ 24.9%
- Cost control: Six years of team control remaining versus Devers’ $313 million extension
Red Sox assistant GM Eddie Romero notes, “Nick’s advanced approach at the plate and natural instincts at first give him a high floor. He’s forcing us to consider accelerating his timeline.”
Statistical Showdown: Comparing the Candidates
When examining the numbers side-by-side, the decision becomes more complex:
| Metric | Devers (2023) | Mayer (AA/AAA 2023) |
|---|---|---|
| OPS | .851 | .890 |
| HR/162G | 33 | 27 (proj.) |
| Defensive Runs Saved | -12 (3B) | +8 (1B) |
While Devers offers proven power in the heart of the order, Mayer provides better defensive value and comparable offensive production in the minors. The Red Sox must determine whether Mayer’s skills will translate against major league pitching.
Team Chemistry and Roster Construction Factors
Beyond statistics, the decision carries significant implications for Boston’s clubhouse dynamics and roster flexibility. Devers has emerged as a team leader since Xander Bogaerts’ departure, while Mayer represents the next wave of homegrown talent. Potential ripple effects include:
- Third base vacancy could allow Triston Casas to shift from DH
- Trade possibilities involving either player to address pitching needs
- Long-term payroll considerations with Devers’ massive contract
Veteran broadcaster Joe Castiglione observes, “This isn’t just about first base—it’s about constructing the best possible infield for the next five years. The Red Sox have to consider how all these pieces fit together.”
Historical Precedents and Position Switch Outcomes
Boston’s front office can look to several historical examples when evaluating a potential Devers position change:
- Miguel Cabrera’s successful transition from 3B to 1B extended his productive years
- Anthony Rizzo improved defensively after moving across the diamond early in his career
- Recent failures like Hanley Ramirez show the risks of forced positional changes
Data from Baseball Prospectus reveals that 68% of third basemen who switched to first base before age 30 maintained or improved their offensive output over the next three seasons. However, only 42% of prospects with Mayer’s profile immediately succeed as everyday first basemen.
Future Outlook and Potential Compromises
As spring training approaches, the Red Sox appear likely to explore hybrid solutions before committing to either option. Possible scenarios include:
- Devers starting at first with Mayer getting regular reps at DH
- A platoon system based on matchups and pitcher handedness
- Mayer beginning in Triple-A for additional seasoning
Ultimately, the decision may come down to whether Boston prioritizes immediate contention or long-term development. With both players offering distinct advantages, the Red Sox’s first base dilemma represents a rare luxury—having multiple high-ceiling options at a premium position. As the season progresses, performance and health will likely determine the final configuration.
For ongoing coverage of this developing story and exclusive insider analysis, subscribe to our Red Sox newsletter below.
See more Highlights Daily
