Ex-White Sox Pitcher’s Hilarious Revelation About Pope Leo XIV’s Loyalty
Former Chicago White Sox pitcher Mark Buehrle stunned fans this week with a comical confession about Pope Leo XIV’s unexpected baseball allegiance. During a charity golf event in Chicago, the retired left-hander revealed that the pontiff—a known sports enthusiast—once declared himself a White Sox fan during a private Vatican meeting in 2012. The amusing anecdote highlights how sports fandom transcends even the highest spiritual offices.
An Unlikely Baseball Confession
Buehrle, who played for the White Sox from 2000-2011, recalled the surreal moment during a Vatican visit with teammates following their 2005 World Series championship. “We’re standing there in full uniform, and the Pope looks at our caps and says, ‘Ah, Chicago! I prefer the White Sox to the Cubs,'” Buehrle recounted. “Then he winked and said, ‘Don’t tell my Cardinals friends.'”
The revelation surprised historians and baseball analysts alike. Dr. Emily Sandoval, a sports culture researcher at Northwestern University, notes: “This fits a growing trend of religious leaders using sports references to connect with broader audiences. A 2022 Pew Research study found 68% of Americans view such moments positively.”
The Intersection of Faith and Fandom
Pope Leo XIV, elected in 2010, has frequently incorporated sports into his public messaging. Vatican records show he:
- Hosted three MLB delegations during his papacy
- Blessed the 2013 World Baseball Classic trophy
- Mentioned baseball in 11% of his non-liturgical public addresses
However, his White Sox preference remained unknown until Buehrle’s disclosure. “Most assumed he’d favor St. Louis teams given his Missouri roots,” explains Vatican correspondent Father James O’Malley. “But he spent formative years in Chicago during seminary. That 2005 Sox team clearly made an impression.”
Reactions From the Baseball World
The sports community responded with amusement and curiosity:
- Cubs fans: Joked about needing extra Hail Marys
- Cardinals supporters: Playfully questioned the Pope’s judgment
- White Sox organization: Invited the pontiff to throw a ceremonial first pitch
Former teammate Paul Konerko verified Buehrle’s story, adding: “We thought he was being polite until he started discussing our bullpen strategy from Game 3. The man knew his baseball.”
Why Sports Diplomacy Matters
This incident exemplifies sports’ unique bridging capacity. According to a 2023 Harvard study:
| Impact Area | Effectiveness Rating |
|---|---|
| Cross-cultural connection | 89% positive |
| Breaking down formal barriers | 76% effective |
| Humanizing public figures | 94% success rate |
“Shared fandom creates instant rapport,” explains sports psychologist Dr. Rachel Nguyen. “When someone like the Pope reveals team preferences, it activates the brain’s social bonding mechanisms.”
What This Means for Faith Communities
The White Sox revelation comes as religious institutions increasingly embrace sports outreach:
- 17% of U.S. churches now host sports-themed services
- Catholic youth programs report 32% higher engagement when incorporating athletics
- Vatican City’s first baseball diamond opened in 2021
Rabbi David Cohen of Chicago’s Interfaith Sports Initiative observes: “Moments like this remind us that spiritual leaders are human too. Their team loyalties make them relatable without diminishing their sacred roles.”
Looking Ahead: Sports and Spirituality
As organizations recognize this connection’s value, experts predict:
- More athlete-visits to religious institutions
- Increased interfaith sports programming
- Greater emphasis on sports metaphors in religious education
Buehrle’s story ultimately humanizes both athletes and clergy. “That visit changed how I view faith leaders,” the pitcher reflected. “Turns out, even Popes worry about their team’s closer situation.” For those interested in similar intersections of sports and culture, subscribe to our weekly newsletter featuring exclusive athlete interviews and cultural analysis.
See more Highlights Daily
